This is just what happens
http://prntscr.com/mihqzBut simulator show me other then that
http://prntscr.com/mii29 (opponent set all reserches 20 (16 his reserches and 4 from alliance) even he doesn't have elite + set premium)
Opponent gets +1500 military points for his alliance.. In my oppinion, this was clearly my win with big military advantage that could win the war so it is really important for my alliance!!!!
Explanations??